Former White House digital-assets adviser Patrick Witt called the Senate’s failure to advance the CLARITY Act “a failure of American leadership” at Solana’s Breakpoint conference in London on November 16. Witt said agency rulemaking and guidance are likely to shape near-term U.S. crypto rules more than congressional action.
Key Takeaways
- Witt cited a shrinking legislative window and debate over ethics provisions tied to Trump family crypto ventures.
- The September 15 motion received 50 votes in favor and 49 against, below the 60-vote threshold.
- Witt expects agencies to fill part of the gap, though narrower legislation could still advance.
- Bitcoin and ether had 24-hour gains on November 16, while XRP and solana were slightly lower; all four had weekly losses.
What happened
Witt said he had spent more than a year negotiating the Clarity Act, but that it “lost against the clock” as the November midterms approached. Witt said ethics concerns tied to the Trump family’s crypto ventures consumed the debate, according to Decrypt’s November 16 report.
The proposed ethics measures included limits on federal officials issuing or sponsoring digital assets, along with divestment or blind-trust requirements for some holdings. Witt said President Trump had agreed to two provisions. This was Witt’s account of negotiations, not a completed agreement or enacted policy.
On September 15, a procedural motion to advance the measure received 50 votes in favor and 49 against, short of the 60 required. Investing.com reported that Republicans Jerry Moran, Susan Collins and Josh Hawley voted against it. Thom Tillis also voted no after changing his position to preserve the option of reconsideration.
Witt’s November comments weren’t a new Senate vote. They underscored the consequences of the September result and the narrowing opportunity to revive the bill before the current Congress adjourns.

Background to the Clarity Act
The Clarity Act proposes a framework for deciding how U.S. digital assets are regulated. The House passed its version, H.R. 3633, on July 17, 2025. A Congressional Research Service overview says it would generally give the Commodity Futures Trading Commission a central role over digital commodities while preserving some Securities and Exchange Commission authority. The Congressional Research Service summary outlines the proposed division of responsibilities.
The proposed framework would define agency roles for digital assets. The Senate measure failed to advance in September, while SEC Chair Paul Atkins and CFTC Chair Mike Selig said their agencies would act under existing authority.
After the vote, SEC Chair Paul Atkins said the agency would use its existing authority to provide certainty. CFTC Chair Mike Selig said the commission was ready to issue rules within its authority, according to The Block. Coinbase CEO Brian Armstrong also said he expected the agencies to begin work on clearer rules.
Witt considers a comprehensive replacement bill unlikely in the near term. He expects market-structure rules to come more through agency rulemaking and Federal Register guidance than a major congressional package. Narrower provisions, including targeted CFTC authority over spot crypto markets, could still advance separately.
Political timing is another constraint. Crypto.news reported on November 15 that incoming Democratic majorities were expected to take control in January 2027, leaving little time for another major attempt in the current Congress. Senator Cynthia Lummis criticized Democrats for opposing the bill, saying it included a mandatory SEC registration process for crypto projects that she described as a consumer-protection measure they had requested.

Market reaction
Available market data doesn’t establish that the Senate setback caused a particular price move. At 22:13 UTC on November 16, CoinGecko’s snapshot showed modest 24-hour gains for bitcoin and ether, while XRP and solana were slightly lower. All four had weekly losses.
| Asset | Price (USD) | 24-hour change | 7-day change |
|---|---|---|---|
| Bitcoin (BTC) | $65,453 | +0.46% | -12.77% |
| Ethereum (ETH) | $1,835.86 | +0.70% | -14.09% |
| XRP | $0.9635 | -0.31% | -12.43% |
| Solana (SOL) | $72.15 | -0.01% | -16.92% |
The Crypto Fear & Greed Index was 10, classified as “Extreme Fear,” on November 16. The four listed assets had weekly losses. These figures do not establish that U.S. legislation affected market prices.

What to watch next
Watch for the SEC or CFTC to issue rules or guidance under their existing authority. Witt said he expected U.S. market-structure rules to come more through agency rulemaking and Federal Register guidance than through Congress.
Witt said a comprehensive replacement bill was unlikely in the near term. He said parts of the bill, including targeted CFTC authority over spot crypto markets, might still be enacted separately.
FAQ
What is the Clarity Act?
It is a proposed U.S. digital-asset market framework. The House-passed version would generally give the CFTC a larger role over digital commodities while retaining some SEC authority, according to the Congressional Research Service.
Why did the Clarity Act fail to advance in the Senate?
The September 15, 2026 procedural motion received 50 votes in favor and 49 against, below the 60 required. Witt also cited time pressure and debate over ethics provisions.
What happens to the Clarity Act now?
Witt said a comprehensive bill is unlikely soon, though narrower measures could advance. The SEC and CFTC may meanwhile pursue rules under their existing authority.
Sources
- An Overview of H.R. 3633, the CLARITY Act (Senator Lummis Draft) (www.everycrsreport.com)
- Clarity Act Defeat ‘Failure of American Leadership’: Trump’s Former Crypto Chief (Decrypt)
- US Senate fails to advance sweeping cryptocurrency bill in blow for industry (www.investing.com)
This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute financial or investment advice. Cryptocurrencies are highly volatile; always do your own research before investing.

